YES. I'd rather go with the current system than the transparency Inc you are advocating.
Sure they can hammer you again. Just don't get into trouble and give them an excuse. The keyword I have for you in your post is why would they hold a personal grudge against you? Have you done anything to anger them?
One of the problems here is that this whole server operates with volunteers, The gamers and the admins alike. And given the maturity level seen in the server and here in forums there is not such thing as a fair and open trial. In the current system some unjust sanctions are given, but I think it still largely works. Do your time, think about what you did and move on. It really is not such a big deal. Nobody is going to Bastille for real. If it was for real then I would take your stance, but it really, really... really is just a game you are willingly playing.
And I think you are given great mercy here in the forums by admins. In other forums you'd be thrown out ages ago. And guess what? Nobody would have cared really. Because the age old rule in servers and forums is that "You either play by the house rules or get out."
If I actually got to decide I would revoke your posting rights here in the forum and let you play instead. It might do you some good.
How about answering the rest of the points, like "What would be Disco like if you had your way?"
