Sweet- I really like the style of the X on the first one (and the last edit). I think I like that X the best.
Now it's a debate between having the glowy lines or not... I kinda like the feel of it without the lines, but it feels empty. Could you make one with the lines behind BOTH of the planets, so you only see it in the middle. Then maybe make them a bit more subtle- so they stand out less. Maybe less bright, or something.
If you have another idea for filler that's not lines maybe try that- but no worries as much there.
Also, I'm debating about having the hard edge planet or not. Is it possible to smooth out the dark side of the hard edge a little more, it seems a bit choppy (like a pentagon maybe). Then for the atmosphere try filling in those two stars that stand out a lot, that could improve the atmosphere a lot.
If you do those, it'll be really close to perfect I'm sure, and I'll have a good one to choose from.
As for text, I'm not sure, I kinda prefer it without, but maybe if you find a different one then you used before but still looks good you could try that. If you don't want to worry about it thats fine too.
Hopefully this isn't too much work.. i'll be around, so just post when you're ready and I'll respond pretty quick. Thanks!
@Dop and anybody else- If he makes one tonight that I like.. then he wins. Sorry:P
So make them quick before I decide. Maybe I'll actually wait a day or so- then pick. Again, no offense to anybody if I don't choose their sig. And I'll probably drill everybody else as much as I am Tenacity:P
Alternate location on the X, I think it makes the two light flares look a little more 'at home':
And the same with the planet edge fixed:
I can move the X back if you want, your choice. I'm also still waiting on ship renders from linkero to add, do you want them in the sig still? With it set up like this I could probably put one ship on each side near the planets.
Hmm I like the second one a lot. Then maybe on one side put that one Raven IMG ship (claw or talon, some day i'll remember) and on the other a Taiidan bomber. Show that last one to me again after Linkero gets the renders, and it'll be sweet.
This looks pretty dang awesome.
BTW, Dab is now in the competition, he's showing them to me over skype. His is pretty good too.. you guys are gonna make it hard to pick... maybe I'll take them all:P
' Wrote:Hmm I like the second one a lot. Then maybe on one side put that one Raven IMG ship (claw or talon, some day i'll remember) and on the other a Taiidan bomber. Show that last one to me again after Linkero gets the renders, and it'll be sweet.
This looks pretty dang awesome.
BTW, Dab is now in the competition, he's showing them to me over skype. His is pretty good too.. you guys are gonna make it hard to pick... maybe I'll take them all:P
do you want the current taiidan bomber, or the one being added in 4.85?
' Wrote:do you want the current taiidan bomber, or the one being added in 4.85?
There's one being added in 4.85!? o.O I wanna see it! And yeah, probably that, since the other one will be outdated soon. I would put a corsair ship but that doesn't match the scene... so yeah, go with that. The new one. (But if it's horribly ugly for some reason... then maybe I'll have second thoughts.)
the new one is a replacement model by jinx, we're trying to get rid of the ugly homeworld models.
Here's two versions - the first uses the model from jinx's ship submission, the second one has the cockpit edited to look a little better (I dont like the color he used on the model cockpit, tbh):
I like the second one a lot! That looks really good!
Just one more thing and I think it'll be perfect-
There is a tiny faint white line below the raven, then a little faint white dot above that. Just erase those quick and it'll be awesome!
Both of these sigs rock so much I don't know what to do...
I'll wait till tomorrow to decide so I can sleep on it, look at them in the morning with a fresh.. err.. look- and maybe giv Dop a chance if he wants it.