House law and Navy ID

[Karst]

I just realized a bit of a problem with the Liberty Navy ID - it can enforce Liberty laws and engage enemies of Liberty, of course, but the ZOI includes Bretonian systems.

It should be modified to something along the lines of "can enforce house law" within their ZOI, because they should be enforcing Bretonian and not Liberty laws when in Bretonia.

The problem here is obvious as Bretonian and Liberty laws differ considerably, and right now they could, for example, engage Rheinland corporate ships or fine Junkers for flying pirate trains in Bretonia.

---

[SnakThree]

They shouldn't be allowed to enforce law in Bretonia either way.

Just shoot Gallics.

---

[Karst]

That would be fine too, and a lot simpler.

---

[Fat_Mendoza]

Agree

[Technogeist]

Yeah that's a bit silly if what you say is true. I cba to check the ID card though so I'll take yer word for it!

[Karst]

The line in question reads "Can attack ships which are in violation of Liberty law or belong to a house or organization considered hostile by Liberty within their Zone of Influence"

---

[SummerMcLovin]

I'm currently going through the IDs fixing things like this, shall add it to the discussion list.

---

Kingdom of Bretonia
Colonial Republic
Independent Miners Guild
Ex-Admin

[Thargoid]

How can you violate the laws of Liberty if you're not actually in Liberty?

If people are actually doing this they should be sanctioned IMO

[Garrett Jax]

How can you violate the laws of Liberty if you're not actually in Liberty?

If people are actually doing this they should be sanctioned IMO

Wow. Just so I'm understanding you correctly here. Are you saying that someone should be sanctioned for following the letter of the law when common sense indicates that he should do otherwise?

---

[Thargoid]

How can you violate the laws of Liberty if you're not actually in Liberty?

If people are actually doing this they should be sanctioned IMO

Wow. Just so I'm understanding you correctly here. Are you saying that someone should be sanctioned for following the letter of the law when common sense indicates that he should do otherwise?

I'm saying the laws of Liberty do not apply unless you are actually in Liberty space, so if a Navy starts enforcing Liberty laws in Bretonia, something should be done about it, FR5, or whatever.

E.G. Liberty Navy spots a Pirate Train in Bretonia, that guy is not breaking the law unless he's flying it in Liberty space. So if a Liberty Navy players pops him, he should be sanctioned etc.

Not sure whether you mis-read my post or I didn't explain it clearly...