I got to page 8 and then stopped reading. Xoria is right here. This really should not come into force. It's granting a carte blanche dictatorship. Not something I ever want to see in anyones hands, other than an admin.
Edit: Just got to Dieters post (98 or 97). Good. As long as there is a guaranteed way for any player to appeal against a denial, my worries are lessened. But it has to be guaranteed to be looked at within a reasonable time scale.
Edit 2: And now Virus post. Yes, that is a way forward I can wholly endorse.