What I'm gathering from the SSs is that NovaPG taunted, 'Scruffy' responded in kind, taunting back at them for losing. Insulting general pirates (IC insults are allowed, as long as it doesn't go overboard..). Then the NovaPG started to threaten to report. Starting the OOC. This seems to me where Scruffy started down the OOC path himself, telling them to go ahead and report it. I think what he said in the SSs can be taken either way. Admins can't be biased, and people's opinions of IC chat differs. Meaning admins would generally have to be lenient about punishing for this particular offense. One person might think he was IC, others might think he is OOC. Unless its obvious, the person can't rightfully be punished, because he might have been in IC, and it just seemed OOC to others.
![[Image: DFinal.png]](http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b328/Luciaden/DFinal.png)