Now, Spazzy, I know you're mostly right, and I honestly don't mind the encounter. Personally, I've had my fun, even if I don't know how to use TS or anything. (In was hugging the BS in the hopes that it would act as a torp magnet, shows you how little I know about PvP)
I think Sarah's point here is more about indie control than it is about how the fight went. What happened to the Rogues that'd make them tolerate OC battleships within Liberty space? Back in the days, you and I as well as the other Rogues killed so, so many OC caps together for shits and giggles. To say that you didn't have control over the indie in Liberty space is just plain lying. Even the Cross, from the logs you've shared, seems to agree that it wasn't his job to leash him. Who's duty was it, then?