"Elite factions"

[Primitive]

This is an interesting discussion. I myself am dealing with just such an issue now, as I try to figure out how to implement the new Ronin faction come 4.86, and I really am conflicted on how to do it. Do I make it an open faction, allowing anyone to fly as an indy? Or do I make it tightly controlled with no-one outside the player faction being allowed to use the ID.

For me there is a balance to a thing like this. If I go with an open ID, it will likely be restricted to just snubcraft. If I go with a closed ID, capital ships will be allowed.

Why is this balance necessary? The RP of the group is that it is very small and mainly snubcraft, if it is given an open ID, there is no way to control the number of people playing the role, but it would be very very bad and counter productive to the storyline of the faction were those players to play lots of caps.

What do you all think? How can a faction who's rp is that is is small and tight night cope with no ability to limit numbers?

Yeah you should open it for all players. I would love to play as ronin when .86 comes out. Who knows maybe I won't have time to be in official faction, or maybe I just won't like people leading it (or they won't like me, we're all humans). Sure you can restrict indies on snubs and give official capital ship or two for their RP purposes and such.

But closing faction which alot of players would love to play would be unfair honestly. Many factions have "serious" rp and they have open ID and such, and those indies maybe act like morons sometimes....but we're still playing a video game remember ?
And if any of those indies goes too much oorp, there are faction rights which can be implemented if one doesn't follow original faction roleplay.