I think you missed my point. I am not insulted personally. My character was because you insulted his leader and his organisation. I did stick in RP. With this post, I am trying to provide a realistic situation within today's parameters to describe my character's role-play, that is all. I am not looking for an OORP fight. I merely wanted the understanding that you know it was all in role-play. Since your statement shows that, I guess my mission was solved.
Also, I don't understand how you can finish a fair investigation without hearing the other side. Natural law, audi et alteram partem and all that. That was all my character was asking for. My character found reason to disagree with your character because he went straight to calling Mr Crow a liar. Without waiting for his evidence. That is where his disagreement lies. It is why my character felt insulted.
Now, whatever other plans for role-play over this issue aside. Are you going to, I don't know, try and kill my character for speaking his mind, or is the matter settled? In other words. Is an supposed insult enough reason to allow other players to kill one another? Now remember, this isn't two pirates. It is a semi-lawful character in disagreement with a lawful faction.