I filed it Sindroms. Personally I found the entire encounter extremely confusing. I also believe that demanding turrets in any way is simply not a fair demand based on how you have to go about it. Yeah the fact that it involves many demands seems to not help. it comes down to whether or not you think it should be allowed to demand someone expose themselves and have their turrets shot off. If not it's not a legit demand, and since followed up your demand to hold with 'dropping' my shield and give up my turrets the hard way, I don't see actions after that as legit. I do want the bottom line drawn on this one either way. Admins need to really reexamine if such rp demands are on the safer side to allow. Should it continue or not? I don't think so but the admins will decide.
If you throw down a demand for something like that don't be surprised if the encounter winds up as uncommon as the demand. Until last week I never made any demand for turrets, and I've pirated a lot of ships. Last week I tried your trick on a trader myself...despite your claims to no problems I ran into the very same confusion right off the bat. But I said until I see a ruling on that I just might roll the way you guys want to. If this stands I'll have no problem settling for cargo or credits. Simple, should rp demands to let yourself get shot to avoid getting shot fly? Barrel rolls don't involve exposing yourself or getting shot. If you want to waive your cargo/ credits right for that...fine. But I think that's what the Terrorist ID is for. Then, if you want to waive your right to kill the target to shoot off their turrets with their consent...well good luck trying. I don't see it as good to allow for a regular ID.