|
This wiki is closed in favour of the new wiki. Information shown is likely to be very out of date. |
Difference between revisions of "Category talk:Player Characters"
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
*It gives Character Bio control over to Joe Blogs. I wouldn't want my stories and Character development so available to be changed. I want them read, not written by other people. The exception is where those other people interact with me in game, so it becomes a collaborative story. | *It gives Character Bio control over to Joe Blogs. I wouldn't want my stories and Character development so available to be changed. I want them read, not written by other people. The exception is where those other people interact with me in game, so it becomes a collaborative story. | ||
*We have LOTS of characters. Just getting the base Discovery information in and maintained is enough work to do. If we add our character Bios it makes ... A LOT more unnecessary work. | *We have LOTS of characters. Just getting the base Discovery information in and maintained is enough work to do. If we add our character Bios it makes ... A LOT more unnecessary work. | ||
| − | *Putting a Character Bio up on the wiki is a personal choice. There are some characters I play that I dont want to put up. Instead of making a main page for the character, I suggest that we put character Bios, under our names. Taking [[Lash McDaggit]] as an example I would put that page under (presumably) [[AndreDelArco]]'s main page as an entry. Not as a main page for Lash McDaggit. | + | *Putting a Character Bio up on the wiki is a personal choice. There are some characters I play that I dont want to put up. Instead of making a main page for the character, I suggest that we put character Bios, under our names. Taking [[Lash McDaggit]] as an example I would put that page under (presumably) [[User:AndreDelArco|AndreDelArco]]'s main page as an entry. Not as a main page for Lash McDaggit. |
The main idea is getting people to the forums. The wiki is a great place for general information (what base, where, what race, how much, weapons,) but not characters. Character information is too fluid for the wiki, I believe. | The main idea is getting people to the forums. The wiki is a great place for general information (what base, where, what race, how much, weapons,) but not characters. Character information is too fluid for the wiki, I believe. | ||
Latest revision as of 21:27, 29 January 2012
I say No to Character Bios on the Wiki
I'm not sure the Wiki is the right place for Character Bios. I think the Forum is a better place for that. It's not my call, but I'm a little uncomfortable with 17,000+ Character Bios on the wiki. We want people to go to the forums.
Why I say no to Character Bios on the wiki:
- The information will change and lots of it will become irrelevant or simply old. What happens if the character dies in the game? (i.e. dies dies.) Do we delete the wiki info? Having a WikiBio creates too much work for the wiki users.
- It gives Character Bio control over to Joe Blogs. I wouldn't want my stories and Character development so available to be changed. I want them read, not written by other people. The exception is where those other people interact with me in game, so it becomes a collaborative story.
- We have LOTS of characters. Just getting the base Discovery information in and maintained is enough work to do. If we add our character Bios it makes ... A LOT more unnecessary work.
- Putting a Character Bio up on the wiki is a personal choice. There are some characters I play that I dont want to put up. Instead of making a main page for the character, I suggest that we put character Bios, under our names. Taking Lash McDaggit as an example I would put that page under (presumably) AndreDelArco's main page as an entry. Not as a main page for Lash McDaggit.
The main idea is getting people to the forums. The wiki is a great place for general information (what base, where, what race, how much, weapons,) but not characters. Character information is too fluid for the wiki, I believe.
Chovynz 19:56, 26 May 2008 (GMT)
/signed
All of mine are on the forums (completed ones that is), and ones in the making I show to Skype buddies.
Boss 01:27, 27 May 2008 (GMT)
Idea: don't put the bios on here, just a summary of the character and a link to their stories. Unless there is a major change, they won't need anything. The wiki has the advantage of being easier to hunt through than the forums, so I think it is a perfect place to put stuff.
Are we at least okay on "important people" having their own mini-articles? You know, people like Queen Carina, Chancellor Reinhardt, Darkstar (Phantoms), maybe even admirals in playerfactions? Sovereign 02:40, 27 May 2008 (GMT)
I agree with what Sovereign says, only important characters go on the wiki. Revion 16:54, 08 June 2009 (CST)
In my opinion, any character biographies should be allowed on the wiki as subpages of the user's page, at least. Characters integral to Discovery lore with enough material to merit creating separate pages for them should be given proper wiki pages. I suggest simply going with "Be Bold" on this issue, if someone adds a character biography to the wiki outside their user page then it could potentially be contested, discussed, and moved as appropriate. -- Eyvind (talk • contrib) 17:03, 8 June 2009 (MDT)
